Was Jesus God? Rethinking the Council of Nicaea

In the fourth century, as Christianity spread across the Roman Empire, the Church found itself divided over one of the most crucial theological questions in its history: Who is Jesus Christ? This question sparked intense debates among bishops and theologians, leading to the first ecumenical council—the Council of Nicaea, convened in 325 CE by Emperor Constantine the Great.

While the council's decision helped define the foundations of Christian orthodoxy, its conclusions continue to be questioned. Many believe that the Nicene Creed contradicted key teachings of Jesus himself, as recorded in the Bible. This article explores the historical context, the central theological debate, and the biblical verses that challenge the Council’s outcome.

Historical Context: Why Nicaea?

After the legalization of Christianity in the Roman Empire through the Edict of Milan (313 CE), theological disputes began threatening the unity of the Church—and by extension, the stability of the empire. Among the most divisive issues was the nature of Christ's divinity.

To resolve this conflict and preserve unity, Constantine summoned over 300 bishops to the city of Nicaea (modern-day İznik, Turkey). His goal was political as much as religious: unify the Church to maintain harmony within the empire. What resulted was not just a theological decision, but a shift in the trajectory of Christian doctrine.

The Core Debate: Arianism vs. Trinitarianism

The dispute focused on the relationship between Jesus (the Son) and God the Father.

🔸 Arianism

Named after Arius, a priest from Alexandria, Arianism held that:

Jesus was a created being who had a beginning.
He was not co-eternal with God the Father.
Jesus was exalted, but not divine in the same way as God.

Arius emphasized biblical passages that highlighted Jesus’ humility, ignorance of certain divine knowledge, and his subordination to the Father.

🔹 Trinitarianism

Opposing Arius was Athanasius, a deacon from Alexandria, who argued that:

Jesus was of the same essence (homoousios) as the Father.
He had no beginning and was eternally begotten, not made.
He was fully God and equally worthy of worship.

This view aimed to preserve the mystery of the Trinity: one God in three persons—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

The Outcome: The Nicene Creed

After heated debates, the Council sided with Athanasius and condemned Arianism as heresy. It produced the Nicene Creed, which declared:

“We believe in one Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God... begotten, not made, of the same essence as the Father, God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God.”

This was a radical theological statement. For the first time, the divinity of Jesus was officially defined and enforced within Christian doctrine. Arius and his followers were exiled, and copies of his writings were ordered to be burned.

But was this definition supported by the words of Jesus himself?

Biblical Passages That Challenge the Nicene Definition

A closer look at the New Testament reveals several verses that seem to contradict the conclusions of Nicaea. These verses emphasize Jesus' humanity, his limitations, and his dependence on God:

📖 Jesus Admits His Inferiority to God

John 14:28 – “The Father is greater than I.”
Mark 13:32 – “No one knows the day or hour... not even the Son, but only the Father.”

These statements directly oppose the idea that Jesus is equal in knowledge and power with the Father.

📖 Jesus Refers to God as “My God”

John 20:17 – “I ascend to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.”
Matthew 27:46 – “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”

If Jesus were truly God, why would he call another being his God?

📖 Jesus Acts as a Messenger of God

Luke 4:43 – “I must preach the good news of the kingdom of God... because that is why I was sent.”
John 7:16 – “My teaching is not my own. It comes from him who sent me.”

Jesus repeatedly emphasizes that his mission, teachings, and authority come from someone higher than himself.

📖 The Bible Affirms God's Oneness

Mark 12:29 – “Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one.”
John 17:3 – “That they may know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent.”

Here, Jesus draws a clear line between himself and the “only true God.”

Conclusion: A Council That Redefined Christianity?

The Council of Nicaea sought to end division within the Church by defining Jesus as fully divine and equal to God the Father. While this brought doctrinal unity to some extent, it also sparked centuries of theological debate and dissent. More importantly, it raised a critical question: Did the Council stay true to the teachings of Jesus, or did it go beyond them?

Many sincere believers and scholars argue that the New Testament itself does not support the claim of Jesus’ divinity as defined in Nicaea. Instead, they point to a Jesus who was deeply spiritual, divinely empowered, but ultimately distinct from God, obedient to God, and sent by God.

In the end, the legacy of the Council of Nicaea is both foundational and controversial—a turning point in Church history that continues to invite reflection, debate, and a return to Scripture.

The Core Dispute

Two major theological camps clashed at the Council:

Arianism, led by a priest named Arius from Alexandria, claimed that:
- Jesus was a created being, not eternal.
- He was subordinate to God the Father.
- Jesus should not be worshipped as equal to God.
Trinitarians, represented by Athanasius (also from Alexandria), argued that:
- Jesus was of the same essence (homoousios) as God.
- He was co-eternal and fully divine.
- Jesus and God were equal and inseparable.

The Council ultimately rejected Arianism and endorsed the Trinitarian view, declaring Jesus as "God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God" in what became known as the Nicene Creed.

But What Does the Bible Say?

Interestingly, several New Testament verses appear to challenge the Council’s conclusion. These verses emphasize Jesus’ humanity, his subordination to God, and his role as a messenger—not as God himself:

John 14:28 – “The Father is greater than I.”
Mark 13:32 – “No one knows the day or the hour… not even the Son.”
John 20:17 – Jesus refers to God as “my God and your God.”
Acts 2:22 – Jesus is described as “a man accredited by God.”
John 17:3 – Calls the Father “the only true God.”

These verses suggest a clear distinction between Jesus and God, contradicting the claim that they are of the same essence.

Final Thoughts

The Council of Nicaea played a pivotal role in shaping Christian doctrine, but its decision to affirm the divinity of Jesus remains controversial. Many biblical passages point to a Jesus who is not equal to God, but rather his servant, messenger, and prophet. As such, the debate over Jesus’ true nature continues to provoke thought and discussion—nearly 1,700 years later.

Written by Parsa Sajedi, a student of theology and seeker of truth

We are made in God's image